The Callisto Protocol review: a stunning, forgettable Dead Space heir
A platinum in 13 hours: gorgeous visuals and a heavy atmosphere, undone by a dodge that kills the tension and an ending held back for DLC.

I just finished The Callisto Protocol in about 13 hours, unlocking all trophies (platinum). I didn’t play the DLCs, and honestly, I won’t. The story DLC alone is around 13€ for roughly 3 hours, even if you take your time, and for me that’s just not worth it.
Starting with the positives, the game is visually stunning. The graphics are genuinely impressive, with incredible character models, lighting, and environmental detail. The atmosphere is also a huge highlight. It clearly leans into that Dead Space-style universe, with a heavy, oppressive tone that works really well. Dark corridors, brutal environments, constant tension: it’s exactly the kind of vibe I like, and on that front, the game delivers.
I honestly enjoyed the experience overall, it’s completely my type of game.
The sound design is also very solid. Every impact, every creature, every movement adds to the immersion. You feel the weight of the world and the danger around you. The soundtrack, however, is much more forgettable. It does the job, but nothing really stands out or sticks with you.
Now, gameplay… this is where things get more mixed.
At the beginning, it’s very repetitive, and that’s actually one of the reasons it took me so long to properly get into the game, even though I bought it day one. It does improve as you progress, with new tools, weapons, and situations, but the core loop doesn’t evolve enough to completely fix that feeling.
The biggest issue for me is the dodge system. It’s just way too easy. Once you understand that it’s basically left and right timing, you can almost play perfectly and take zero damage. That completely removes tension from combat, which is a huge problem for a survival horror game. Instead of feeling dangerous, fights become predictable and mechanical.
Enemy variety is also somewhat limited, and encounters start to feel similar over time. Combined with the repetitive structure, it makes parts of the game feel a bit dragged out, even if the overall length is actually quite good.
The story is very basic. It’s not bad, but it’s something we’ve seen many times before. It lacks originality and doesn’t really surprise you. And the biggest frustration comes from the ending, which feels like a setup for the DLC. It’s a bit of a cliffhanger, and knowing that the conclusion is locked behind a paid DLC makes it even worse.
In terms of progression, upgrades and weapons are decent but not particularly deep. There are some interesting ideas, especially with the GRP system, but again, nothing that truly elevates the experience to another level.
Verdict
In the end, The Callisto Protocol is a good but very forgettable game. It looks amazing, has a great atmosphere, and if you love this kind of universe, you’ll probably enjoy it. But it’s held back by repetitive gameplay, lack of depth, and questionable design choices, especially around combat and its ending.
I enjoyed my time with it, but it’s not something that will stay with me for long.
For me, it’s around a 6.5/10.
Played on: PlayStation 5, 13 hours, all trophies.
Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then fact-checked, edited and approved by an Akavish editor, who is responsible for it.


