Skip to content
← Back
Review8/10

Silent Hill f review: a new direction that pays off

Eighteen hours in 1960s rural Japan: a beautiful, disturbing and very different Silent Hill.

By Akavish· · 3 min read· Silent Hill f
Silent Hill f: official screenshot

I just finished the story of Silent Hill f after 18 hours on Steam, about 11 of them on my actual save file, with 22 out of 56 trophies unlocked, and I played the whole thing on Hard combat and Hard puzzles. I won't be going for the platinum. Getting there means replaying the game several times to unlock the other endings and sweep up every collectible, and that's just not something I'm interested in doing. I came for the story, I got the story, and that's what matters to me.

And what a story it is. Moving the series to 1960s rural Japan is easily the boldest thing Konami could have done with Silent Hill, and it works far better than it had any right to. Ebisugaoka doesn't feel like a reskin of an American small town, it feels genuinely, specifically Japanese, and the horror grows out of that setting rather than being dropped on top of it. Hinako's story is about arranged marriage, an abusive father, the suffocating expectations placed on a teenage girl in that era, and the monsters are direct expressions of all of it. Ryukishi07's writing is dense and deliberately obscure in places, but it rewards you for paying attention, and the way the real town and the Dark Shrine bleed into each other kept me hooked from start to finish.

The art direction is stratospheric. The red spider lilies creeping over everything, the fog, the rot, the creature designs that are genuinely beautiful and genuinely repulsive at the same time, all of it adds up to one of the most distinctive-looking horror games I've played in years. The atmosphere is horribly oppressive in the best possible way. It's not built on jump scares, it's built on constant, low-level dread, and the sound design holds that tension in every corridor. Akira Yamaoka's music does a huge amount of the work here, blending traditional Japanese instrumentation into the series' familiar industrial unease.

The puzzles are another highlight, and I'm glad I put them on Hard. They're properly obtuse in the old-school Silent Hill sense, the kind that make you write things down and actually think, and they never felt unfair. That's rare now.

Combat is where things get more complicated for me. The systems themselves are good. Melee weapons break, so you're constantly deciding whether a fight is worth the durability. Sanity doubles as both your resource for Focus and your buffer against psychological attacks, and on Hard your maximum sanity shrinks every time you eat a hit while focused, which puts real long-term weight on every mistake. Faith and the Hokora shrines tie exploration back into your survivability. On paper it all clicks.

In practice it runs out of steam. The weapon pool is small, the enemy variety is thin, and because everything is melee you end up doing the same handful of things for eighteen hours: focus, read the tell, dodge, counter, swing. The encounters stop teaching you anything fairly early, and after that they're just friction between story beats.

The odd thing is that I never really missed having firearms, which I honestly didn't expect to say. Hinako isn't a soldier, she's a teenager swinging a pipe, and the clumsy, desperate weight of that suits the character perfectly. What I did miss was any kind of ranged dimension at all. There are no ranged enemies to speak of, nothing that forces you to reposition or manage space, so every fight collapses into the same close-quarters rhythm. Even one or two enemy types that attacked from a distance would have shaken the whole thing up.

Tellingly, the Dark Shrine sections are where the combat is at its best, precisely because that's where you get powers and unbreakable weapons and the moveset finally opens up. Those stretches have the variety the rest of the game is missing, and I found myself wishing the game had leaned harder into them.

None of that stopped me loving it. The frustrating part is that everything around the combat is so strong: the setting, the writing, the visuals, the sound, the puzzles, the sheer confidence of the whole thing. It's the most interesting Silent Hill has been in twenty years, and I hope this is the direction the series keeps going.

Verdict

Overall, I'd give it an 8/10. A genuinely fresh, beautiful and deeply unsettling take on the series that's held back only by a combat loop that never grows past its opening hours.

Played on: PC (Steam), 17.9 hours.

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then fact-checked, edited and approved by an Akavish editor, who is responsible for it.

Liked this? Get the newsletter

The week’s biggest gaming news, leaks and reviews in your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

Read next