Skip to content
← Back
Review6/10

Nobody Wants to Die review: an average game held up by an extraordinary world

A stunning retrofuturist noir in 2329 New York, with great crime scenes and voice acting, but choices that never change anything.

By Akavish· · 3 min read· Nobody Wants to Die
Nobody Wants to Die: official screenshot

I just finished Nobody Wants to Die in 6.2 hours, with all 26 of the 26 trophies, most of which came easily. I liked it, genuinely, but it is an average game held up by an extraordinary world.

The setting is the reason to play it. New York, 2329, in a world where humanity has solved death. A substance called ichorite stores a person's consciousness and lets them be transferred into a new body, so the wealthy simply keep going for centuries. You play James Karra, a 120-year-old detective whose mind is fraying, handed an off-the-books case investigating the death of one of the city's most influential men, with a police liaison named Sara Kai feeding you information remotely. The aesthetic fuses forties and fifties noir with retrofuturism and cyberpunk, and since I love both of those things separately, seeing them combined this well was a treat.

The gameplay is built around crime scene investigation from a first-person view. Each scene gives you a set of tools and asks you to rebuild what happened. The Reconstructor is the centrepiece: it lets you scrub a moment in time backwards and forwards like a video, freezing the scene mid-action so you can walk around a body suspended in the air and work out the sequence of events. Alongside it you get an ultraviolet light for traces the eye cannot see and an X-ray view for what is hidden behind surfaces. You piece the findings onto an evidence board, then the game asks you to draw the conclusion yourself by linking clues together. When it works, it is genuinely satisfying, and the theatrical staging of a frozen crime scene is unlike anything else I have played.

The catch is that the investigation is more guided than it looks. You rarely fail, the game nudges you firmly toward the right answer, and getting a deduction wrong costs you nothing. So it becomes an elaborate presentation layer over a story that was going to advance regardless. Between scenes you are mostly walking, listening, and picking dialogue options in Karra's apartment or over the radio with Sara.

Visually it is stunning. It is clearly a demanding game, and it shows: the lighting, the reflections, the density of the environments. The music is fine, nothing more, but the voice acting is genuinely excellent and does a lot of the work in pulling you into the world. The story is good, maybe even very good.

And here is the real problem. None of your choices matter. The game constantly tells you they do, flagging decision after decision as consequential, and then nothing changes. Whatever you do, the entire adventure plays out identically, and you arrive at the same point with two endings available, one good and one bad, picked at the last moment. That is it. Everything before it was theatre. Which means this is closer to an episode of a series or a film than a game, and it is a shame, because the universe and the ideas were there for something like Detroit: Become Human. The one trophy quirk follows from it: there is an achievement per ending, so you have to replay to get both, which in my case took very little time precisely because nothing branches.

Verdict

Overall, I'd give it a 6/10, and that is largely for the world. A beautiful, well-acted noir with a fantastic premise that never becomes the game it keeps promising to be.

Played on: PC (Steam), 6.2 hours.

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then fact-checked, edited and approved by an Akavish editor, who is responsible for it.

Liked this? Get the newsletter

The week’s biggest gaming news, leaks and reviews in your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

Read next