Skip to content
← Back
Review8.5/10

Mafia: The Old Country review: a return to what made Mafia great

Fifteen and a half hours in Sicily: a short, dense, cinematic mob story, best played in Sicilian with subtitles.

By Akavish· · 2 min read· Mafia: The Old Country
Mafia: The Old Country: official screenshot

I just finished Mafia: The Old Country with about 15.7 hours of playtime, unlocking 42 out of 55 trophies, and honestly I loved every single minute of it.

This is exactly the kind of experience I want more of. The game is relatively short, yes, but it’s packed with quality from start to finish. Every cinematic, every dialogue, every mission feels like you’re part of a true mafia movie. You’re not just playing, you’re inside it. You feel involved in every relationship, every decision, every conversation. It’s incredibly immersive.

And I have to say it clearly, you absolutely need to play it in Sicilian with subtitles. It completely transforms the experience. The authenticity, the tone, the emotion, everything feels more real and impactful. It adds a layer of immersion that is honestly rare in games.

Visually, the game is beautiful. The artistic direction is insane, and the representation of Sicily is stunning. Landscapes, villages, lighting, everything contributes to building a believable and captivating world. You really feel transported there.

The soundtrack and voice acting are also incredible. The music perfectly supports the atmosphere, and the performances are top tier. Everything is extremely well written and delivered, which reinforces that strong cinematic feeling from beginning to end.

Gameplay is probably the weakest part. Action sequences can feel a bit repetitive, and hand-to-hand combat lacks depth and becomes redundant over time. But honestly, it doesn’t really matter. You’re not playing this for complex mechanics, you’re playing it like you would watch a movie, and in that sense, it works perfectly.

Performance is solid overall, and combined with the strong visuals, it makes for a very smooth and enjoyable experience.

Verdict

In the end, Mafia: The Old Country is a focused, cinematic, story-driven experience that respects your time while delivering something memorable. I genuinely wish we had more games like this, shorter but dense, polished, and impactful.

I absolutely loved it.

For me, it’s an easy 8.5/10.

Played on: PC (Steam), 15.7 hours.

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then fact-checked, edited and approved by an Akavish editor, who is responsible for it.

Liked this? Get the newsletter

The week’s biggest gaming news, leaks and reviews in your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

Read next