Skip to content
← Back
Review6.5/10

Mafia III review: an amazing story stuck in a repetitive open world

Thirty-eight hours in 1968 New Bordeaux: a brilliant story and soundtrack, buried under endless points of interest.

By Akavish· · 2 min read· Mafia III
Mafia III: official screenshot

I finally finished Mafia III. I started it back when it came out, stopped, and only remember thinking: what a boring game. I'm a huge fan of the Mafia series and have played every game, remake and remaster, so in 2024 I decided to replay the whole series and finally complete the third one.

The story is the best part

The intro is a masterpiece. It's linear, but the storytelling and the context are excellent, and the recreation of New Orleans (New Bordeaux in the game) is so faithful that it's perfect. The story is the game's biggest strength, and it's what kept me going despite everything I disliked. It's amazing.

The art direction is stunning: the bayou, the districts and the roads bring the 1960s South to life. And the soundtrack deserves a huge shout-out. It's perfect.

The open world is the problem

Mafia III feels like a Ubisoft-style open world, and arguably worse: I have never seen so many points of interest on a map in my life, so many that the map sometimes lags. Having that many doesn't make a game full or long, it just makes it annoying. I'm a big completionist, and this endless chain of "go there, do this, go to the next one" is repetitive. It isn't a good open world.

The missions can be summed up like this: talk to someone, cause a certain amount of chaos in their district, talk to them again, kill the local mini-boss, unlock a story mission. And that's it, for more than 30 hours, without ever changing. The side quests are poor in story and offer nothing beyond clearing icons, to the point that 100% completion felt like a waste of time.

The gunplay and driving are standard: the driving is pretty good and the guns feel fine, but movement is sometimes awkward. The graphics aren't great either, and the frame rate was low even on my PC (Intel Core i9, RTX 3090 Ti) in 2024.

Verdict

A good game with an amazing story in the best possible setting, the Mafia in 1960s New Orleans, with a superb soundtrack and a faithful recreation of the period. But the gameplay and execution are poor, and the side content is a pile of things to do just to say there's a lot of content. It would have been better as 15 hours of story missions without the open world.

Played on: PC (Steam), 38.4 hours.

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then fact-checked, edited and approved by an Akavish editor, who is responsible for it.

Liked this? Get the newsletter

The week’s biggest gaming news, leaks and reviews in your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

Read next