Gears of War: Reloaded review: a great co-op throwback that shows its age
Finished in a single day in co-op on Insane: a clean, stable remaster that keeps the old Gears feel, and its repetition with it.

We played Gears of War Reloaded entirely in co-op, on the highest difficulty, and finished it in one single day. And honestly? It was a real pleasure… with some very clear limits.
First of all, the technical side is great. The game looks really good: clean, fluid, well remastered, and very stable. It’s clearly not some crazy Unreal Engine 5 showcase, and that’s actually a good thing. It keeps that old-school Gears identity, that slightly stiff, heavy feeling that defines the franchise. Visually, it respects the original while modernising it just enough to be enjoyable today.
Playing it in co-op is still where the game shines the most. Cover-based combat, pushing together, reviving each other, advancing room by room—it’s still effective and satisfying on a moment-to-moment basis. As a shared experience, it works extremely well, especially if you’re doing it in one go with a friend.
That said… in 2026, the game has clearly lost a lot of its flavour.
The biggest issue is repetition. The structure is extremely rigid: advance, take cover, kill waves of enemies, move forward, repeat. On Insane difficulty, this becomes even more obvious. Enemies turn into pure bullet sponges with near-aimbot accuracy, which doesn’t really add depth—just frustration and exhaustion. It feels less tactical and more about endurance and patience.
Enemy variety is limited, encounters start to blend together, and after a few hours, the formula becomes very predictable and very tiring. What was groundbreaking at the time now feels dated. Not bad—just clearly from another era.
The atmosphere, soundtrack, and overall tone are still solid. The dark, gritty universe works, and the game still has that raw, brutal identity that made Gears famous. But narratively and mechanically, it doesn’t evolve much, and by today’s standards, it lacks nuance and variety.
Verdict
In the end, I’d say it was a great nostalgic co-op experience, and I’m really glad I replayed it with a friend, especially in one intense session. But it’s also a reminder of how much game design has evolved. Fun, well-remastered, and enjoyable—but undeniably dated, repetitive, and less impactful than it once was.
A good experience, a cool throwback, but no longer a genre-defining one.
Played on: Xbox Series X|S, 9 hours 30 minutes, in co-op.
Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then fact-checked, edited and approved by an Akavish editor, who is responsible for it.


