Skip to content
← Back
Review8/10

Gears of War 4 review: the underrated one is our favourite

Ten hours in co-op on max difficulty: the first Gears that truly evolves the formula, with real variety, storms and a cast that works.

By Akavish· · 2 min read· Gears of War 4
Gears of War 4: official screenshot

We finished Gears of War 4 in co-op, on the maximum difficulty, in about 10 hours, and honestly… both my friend and I completely agree on one thing:

We genuinely do not understand why the game is rated lower by so many players and reviews compared to the original trilogy.

For us, Gears of War 4 is easily the best of the four games so far.

The biggest reason is simple: the game finally evolves the formula in meaningful ways. The gameplay feels so much more modern and dynamic, with far more variety in combat situations, environments, enemy encounters, and pacing. Unlike the previous games, where you often felt stuck fighting the same enemies with the same weapons in the same gray ruined environments for hours, Gears 4 constantly changes things up, and it makes a huge difference.

The campaign feels fresher, more alive, and much less repetitive overall.

Visually, the jump is absolutely massive. Of course it’s not the same generation as the first trilogy, but still, the graphical leap is crazy. The game is genuinely beautiful at times. Lighting, weather effects, environments, destruction, animations… everything feels far more polished and cinematic. Some sequences are honestly spectacular.

The storms and environmental effects especially add a lot to the gameplay. They’re not just visual gimmicks either, they actively change fights and create some very memorable moments during the campaign.

Gameplay-wise, it’s still classic Gears at its core: cover-based shooting, heavy weapons, executions, chainsaws, explosions everywhere. But movement feels smoother, weapons feel better, and combat encounters are designed in a much more interesting way. The difficulty on max setting was also genuinely challenging without constantly feeling unfair.

The story is another point where we honestly disagree with the general opinion. I think a lot of people were simply upset because the original characters were no longer the main focus. But objectively speaking, the narrative has more depth, better pacing, and stronger character interactions than some of the previous games.

The new cast actually works really well. Relationships feel more natural, dialogues are better written, and the game spends more time developing its characters instead of only throwing nonstop action at you. It still has that blockbuster Gears energy, but with a bit more humanity and emotional nuance.

The soundtrack and sound design are also excellent. Weapons sound brutal, environments feel alive, and the overall atmosphere remains true to the franchise while modernizing it.

Of course, some classic Gears problems are still there. Enemies can still feel like bullet sponges sometimes, and the structure remains fairly linear. But compared to the first trilogy, the game does a much better job at hiding repetition through variety and pacing.

Verdict

In the end, Gears of War 4 surprised us in the best possible way.

Where the first games increasingly felt like repetitive but fun “turn your brain off” shooters, this one actually felt more ambitious, more polished, more varied, and simply more enjoyable from beginning to end.

For now, it’s clearly our favorite of the franchise.

Played on: Xbox One, 10 hours, in co-op on the hardest difficulty.

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then fact-checked, edited and approved by an Akavish editor, who is responsible for it.

Liked this? Get the newsletter

The week’s biggest gaming news, leaks and reviews in your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

Read next